Friday wasn’t the first time Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy clashed with an American president – President Biden once hung up on him because of the Ukrainian president’s perceived combativeness, sources familiar with the call told CBS News. The friction was kept private.
(by Caitlin Doornbos, NY Post) – KYIV — President Trump’s special envoy to the Ukraine War urged Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky to sign the now-deferred mineral rights deal with Washington during the envoy’s visit to Kyiv last week, but Zelensky’s chief of staff insisted on the Friday Oval Office signing that went badly awry, a senior US official involved with the talks told The Post.
After three days of intense negotiations, retired Gen. Keith Kellogg secured the long-sought agreement with Ukraine that would have provided Washington with 50% of all future proceeds from the European country’s lucrative critical and rare-earth minerals.
“Kellogg and Zelensky had agreed to a deal with one item still to be finalized,” the US official said of the talks that concluded Feb. 21.
As negotiations wrapped up, Zelensky chief of staff Andrii Yermak pushed for the Ukrainian president to join Trump at the White House to sign the agreement.
Kellogg “advised against it, knowing that the relationship [between the presidents] needed to be strengthened” before meeting in-person, according to the official.
However, a source familiar with Yermak’s tactics said Zelensky’s office “continued to force the issue.”
Kellogg was ready to walk away, nearly leaving Ukraine without a deal to present Trump.
However, Zelensky’s office reversed course at the last minute after the retired general boarded his train to Poland, apparently recognizing Kellogg was their best shot at mending frayed relations with the US president.
Impressed by Kellogg’s straightforward negotiations and displays of respect throughout — including a visit with wounded Ukrainian troops in a military hospital northwest of Kyiv — Zelensky’s office rushed documents to the train that Kellogg could take back to Trump.
Even after the close call, Kyiv pushed forward with the plan to seal the deal in Washington — a gamble that backfired Friday when Zelensky got into a heated exchange with Trump and Vice President JD Vance at the White House and was subsequently booted out of the West Wing.
“Zelensky played it as wrong as he could play it,” the senior US official said. “He came into the Oval acting like a tough guy. It didn’t play well. Everyone in the room felt insulted.”…
Zelensky claimed during a press conference Wednesday that he had been invited to the White House, but it was unclear whether he was referring to a standing offer or if an invite had been issued specifically to sign the agreement.
Multiple Ukrainian sources told The Post this week they suspected the Zelensky team forced the White House visit. …
Zelensky’s cabinet of ministers ratified the mineral agreement in Kyiv on Thursday, Ukrainian parliamentary sources said.
The only thing left to do was for Zelensky to sign the document, which never took place after the dramatic display before the world’s press in the Oval Office.
The verbal volleys left Kyiv reeling Friday night, with Ukrainians who spoke to The Post disagreeing over which country’s president was more at fault.
The paradox facing Zelensky is that while many Ukrainians rallied behind him after some of Trump’s earlier affronts — such as dubbing him a “dictator” last week — they also understand they need the US as a partner to defeat Moscow’s invasion once and for all.
Published at NYPost .com. Reprinted here for educational purposes only. May not be reproduced on other websites without permission.
NOTE: Questions are based on the videos under "Resources" below. The 2nd video is the entire 49 minute press conference. Questions for that are based on the first 3 minutes of the video.
1st Video: Watch the segment from the Feb. 28 Jesse Watters show. Watters points out in the beginning of his commentary: "The first 30 minutes went great...Everyone seemed friendly... Then for some reason Zelensky got an attitude."
1. After he notes (around 2:30) "What good does it do for Zelensky to call us naive? We're not naive.... What question does Watters ask about a deal between Ukraine and Russia?
2. Zelensky warns (3:15) that the U.S. will feel [Russian aggression] in the future. Trump replies "Don't tell us what we're going to feel. We're trying to solve a problem.... You're in no position to dictate what we're going to feel. ... You don't have the cards right now.
What does he tell Zelensky he is gambling with?
3. Around 4:12 what does Watters say about a security deal?
4. Watters asserts "Ukraine's in no position to negotiate terms. We're in charge. He can either accept it, fight Russia himself or look for another sponsor." What credit does he give Zelensky and the Ukrainians?
5. Zelensky tells Trump (7:10) "We've been alone." Trump says "you haven't been alone." How much does he say the U.S. has given Ukraine during President Biden's term?
6. Watters says (7:40) "We're not here to debate. You can debate behind the scenes. You can debate at lunch. But if you debate in the open like this you're gonna lose because Ukraine has no leverage. The minerals were their only leverage and without those you're not getting a peace deal.
At a certain point it didn't even look like Zelensky wanted peace." Watching these clips (and below the Watters video is the full 50 minute press conference), what do you think of President Zelensky's decision to agree to sign the deal, insist on coming to the White House to sign it, and then insist on a "security guarantee" as he took time to air out these grievances in front of the camera? Ask a parent what he/she thinks of the situation.
2nd Video: The full press conference was long. Only the last 10 minutes or so were contentious. Watch the first 3 minutes of President Trump's introductory remarks to answer #7 and 8.
7. How does President Trump characterize the Ukrainian soldiers?
8. What is the tone of President Trump's remarks?