NOTE: the "coalition" refers to the U.S. and our allies, as well as Afghan military and police

1. What unusual tactic have the U.S. and our allies in Afghanistan taken in the fight against the Taliban? Be specific.

2. According to Col. Shanks, "If we went in there one night and all the insurgents were gone and we didn't have to fire a shot, that would be a success."  If this happens, where do you think the Taliban fighters will go?  Explain your answer.

3. What added dangers will coalition troops face by opting against a surprise attack?

4. What positive effect has announcing the offensive already had in Marjah, according to Brig. Gen. Larry Nicholson?

5. Why does the coalition think that public warnings of the impending offensive will limit civilian causalities?

6. In addition to limiting civilian causalities, what advantage is there to alerting local populations to coalition plans, according to Mr. O'Hanlon?

7. Do you think alerting the Taliban to coalition plans is good strategy? Explain your answer.